Document Type : Original Article
Author
Department of Islamic Philosophy and Kalam" Faculty of Theology and Islamic Studies
Abstract
ناصر بن علی قفاری از اساتید سلفی دانشگاه محمد بن سعود در کتاب «اصول مذهب الشیعه الامامیه، عرض و نقد» به نقد آرای شیعیان پرداخته است. فصل نخستین کتاب او دیدگاه شیعیان درباره قرآن را به بوته نقد کشیده است. مساله تحریف قرآن یکی از موضوعات مطرح در این بخش است.از نظر او شیعیان از دیرباز باور به تحریف قرآن داشته اند. او با استفاده از برخی از منابع شیعی مانند کتاب «فصل الخطاب فی تحریف کتاب رب الارباب» میرزا حسین نوری، و با نظر به برخی از روایات کتاب کافی، شیخ کلینی را از باورمندان به تحریف قرآن دانسته است. این نوشته ادعاهای او را بررسی کرده و نشان می دهد که شیخ کلینی هرگز ادعای باور به تحریف قرآن را مطرح نکرده و از روایات کافی نیز چنین انگاره ای استخراج نمی شود از سویی شواهد و قرائنی وجود دارد که نشان می دهد شیخ کلینی معتقد به تحریف قرآن نبوده است.
Keywords
Ali bin Ibrahim Qomi. (1983). Tafsir al-Qami. Qom: Tayyab Mousavi Jazaeri Press. [in Arabic]
Abu Omar Dani, Usman bin Said. (1994). The statement in the number of verses of the Qur'an. Research: Ghanem Qadouri Al-Hamd Al-Kuwait Center for Manuscripts and Heritage. [in Arabic]
Ehsanifar Langroudi, Mohammad. (contemporary); Negation of the distortion of Sahih Hisham in "Al-Kafi"; Collection of Persian Articles of the International Congress of Thagha-e-Islam Klini, Vol. 5, pp. 193-217; Qom Dar al-Hadith 2008 pp. 197-198. [in Persian]
Feiz Kashani (1985). Alwafi Isfahan: Amir al-Momenin Library. [in Persian]
_______. (n.d.). Tafsir Asfi Research of Tehran Islamic Research and Research Center: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance. C2. P. 1162.
_______. (1995). Tafsir Safi second edition. Tehran: Sadr Library. [in Persian]
Ghazi Na’man Maghrebi, Abu Hanifa Noman bin Muhammad. (1993). Sharh al-Akhbar in the virtues of the imams of the pure. Research: Second Edition. Seyyed Mohammad Hosseini Jalali, Islamic Publications.
Ghafari, Naser bin Ali. Criticism and analysis of the foundations and principles of the Twelve Imam Shia religion. N.p. N.d.
Hosseini Qazvini, Seyyed Mohammad. (2009). Criticism of the book Usul Madhhab al-Shia. Qom: Wali Asr Institute (AJ). [in Persian]
Hali, Hassan bin Suleiman. (1950). A summary of Basa'er al-Deraj Najaf Ashraf's pamphlets of Heydarieh Press. Qom: Al-Rasoul Al-Mustafa (PBUH) Publications. [in Persian]
Ibn Hazm Ali Ibn Ahmad. (1995). Al-Chapter in Al-Mullam, Al-Ahwa, and Al-Nahl Mohshi Ahmad Shamsuddin. Beirut: Dar al-Katb Al-Alamiya. [in Arabic]
Ibn Shazan (1984). Al-Ayadah Research: Al-Sayed Jalaluddin Al-Hussaini Al-Armowi Al-Muhaddath. Tehran: Publishing and Printing Institute of Tehran University. [in Persian]
Javadinia, Hossein and Rafat Nejad, Mohammad Taghi (2017) . "Criticism of Ghafari's view on Kafi book". Number 14 of Shia studies. Spring and summer.
Khoi, Abulqasem. (1990). Bayan in Tafsir al-Qur'an. Beirut: Dar Al-Zahra. fourth edition. 1975-1395 pp. 197-200. [in Arabic]
Karimian Mahmoud; (2008). Protection of the Qur'an from distortion in al-Kafi hadiths; A collection of Persian articles of the international congress of Thagha-e-Islam Kalini. Volume 5, pp. 157-73. Qom: Dar al-Hadith. pp. 119-120. [in Persian]
Kilini, Muhammad bin Yaqub. (1984). Al-Kafi Edited by: Ali Akbar Ghafari, 5th edition, Tehran, Darul Kitab al-Islamiya. [in Persian]
Majlesi, Mohammad Baqir bin Mohammad Taghi. (1983). Bahar Al-Anwar second edition. Beirut: Al-Wafa. [in Arabic]
_____________________. (1983). Mirror of wisdom Tehran: Darul Kitab al-Islamiya.
Moradian, Forough; Mostafid, Hamidreza. Analysis of opinions and hadith methods. Mohammad Baqer Behbodhi in Sahih al-Kafi book with emphasis on the book on the causes of hadith Namah al-Hiyat. 12th year The forty-ninth issue of Winter 2018. pp. 86-62.
Mufid, Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Nu'man. (1993). The beginning of the articles in al-Mahabh and al-Mukhtarat. Beirut: Dar al-Mufid. [in Arabic]
Mullah Saleh Mazandarani. (2000). The description of the principles is sufficient. Comments: Mirza Abul Hasan She’rani. Dar Ehiya al-Traath al-Arabi. [in Arabic]
Mirzaei Nouri, Hossein bin Mohammad Taghi. (n.d.). The chapter of the speech in the distortion of the book Rab al-Arbab. Lithography. N.p.
Najarzadegan, Fathullah. (contemporary). A reflection on the hadiths of Tahrif al-Kafi's view. A collection of Persian articles of the international congress of Thagha-e-Islam Kalini. Volume 5. pp. 157-193. Qom: Dar al-Hadith. 2017 pp. 161-162. [in Persian]
___________. (2003). Salam al-Qur'an, I am Tahrif. Tehran: Mash’ar. [in Persian]
Najashi, Abu al-Abbas Ahmed bin Ali. (1995). Fifth Edition. Rijal al-Najashi Qom: Islamic Publications. [in Arabic]
Salim bin Qais Helali. (2001). Salim's book Research: Ansari, Mohammad Baqer. Qom: Dalil Ma. [in Arabic]
Saduk (1993). Beliefs in the Imami religion. Research: Essam Abdul Sayed. second edition. Beirut: Dar al-Mufid. [in Arabic]
____. (n.d.). The reasons for submission. Sayyid Mohammad Sadiq Bahrul Uloom. Najaf: Al-Haidariyeh Library. [in Arabic]
Safar, Muhammad bin Al-Hassan. (1983). Basaer al-Deraj. Researcher: Mirza Hasan Kuche Baghi. Tehran: Scientific Publications. [in Persian]
Tabarsi (1995). Tafsir of Majam al-Bayan. Beirut: Al-Alami Publishing House. [in Arabic]
Tusi, Muhammad bin Hassan. (1983). The authority of men's knowledge. Qom: Al-Al-Bayt (AS) Institute.[1] [in Persian]
)