Comparative Shiʿi Theology

Investigation and Criticism of the Positivist View of Auguste Comte about the Origin of Religion Based on the Fitrà Theory of Shahid Motahhari

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Abdullah Hosseini Eskandian 1
Ghorban-Ali Karimzadeh Gharamaleki 2

1 Thelogy master student

2 Associate of Tabriz University

https://doi.org/10.22054/jcst.2024.74084.1132
Abstract
One of the important issues that is raised today in the philosophy of religion and the new theology is the question of the origin of religion and how it came into existence. Religion is a phenomenon that mankind has been dealing with for a long time, and no era can be found in which religion does not exist. The origin of this important issue has always involved the minds of many sages and different views have been formed around this issue. Auguste Comte, the famous French sociologist, considers the origin of religion to be human ignorance and believes that the age of religion is over. On the other hand, Shahid Motahhari, who is one of the most prominent contemporary Islamic thinkers, has expressed detailed discussions about religion and its origin in his various works. Shahid Motahhari believes that the origin of religion is human nature, that man has a natural inclination towards religion and belief in the One God, and human factors cannot be the origin of religion. In this article, with the descriptive-analytical method, while explaining Comte's point of view, it is criticized based on Shahid Motahhari's Fitrà theory. Comte`s simplistic view of religion and reaching a paradox that he himself admitted to cannot be resolved with his evolutionary and functional equivalence theories and invalidates his view.

Keywords

Religion
Auguste Komte
Origin of Religion
Shahid Motahhari
Positivist
Fitrà Theory
 
References [In Persian]
The Holy Quran
Nahj al-Balagha (2011), translated by Mohammad Dashti, fourth edition. Tehran: Jelveh Kamal Publications. [In Persian]
Azarbaijani, Masoud. (2016) Psychology of religion from the point of view of William James, Qom. [In Persian]
Faramarz Qaramalki, Ahad (2013), Master of Motahari and New Kalam, Tehran: Research Institute of Islamic Culture and Thought, first edition. [In Persian]
Faramarz Qaramalki, Ahad (2012), the epistemological function of nature in the thought of Professor Motahari, Qabasat, third year, second issue. [In Persian]
Ghaeminia, Alireza (2000), An Introduction to the Origin of Religion, Qom: Ma'arif Publications, first edition. [In Persian]
Hassani, Seyyed Hamidreza; Mousavi, Hadi (2017), Positivist anthropology as the anthropological foundations of Auguste Comte and Emile Durkheim, Tehran: Howzah and University Research Institute. [In Persian]
Hosseini, Seyed Akbar; Khavas, Amir (2008), Origin of Religion (Review and Criticism of Views), Tehran: Young Thought Center Publications, first edition. [In Persian]
Hamilton, Malkom (2012), Sociology of Religion, translated by Mohsen Salasi, Fourth Edition, Tehran: Sales Publications. [In Persian]
Jafari, Mohammad Taqi (1999), Philosophy of Religion, Tehran: Research Institute of Islamic Thought and Culture, first edition. [In Persian]
Javadi Amoli, Abdullah (2001), Man's Expectation from Religion, researched and compiled by Mohammad Reza Mostafapour, Qom: Asra Publishing House, second edition. [In Persian]
Motahari, Morteza (2010), Principles of Philosophy and the Method of Realism, 14th edition, Tehran: Sadra Publications. [In Persian]
Motahari, Morteza (1997), Adl Elahi, Tehran, Sadra, 11th edition. [In Persian]
Motahari, Morteza (1995), collection of works, Tehran: Sadra Publishing House, first edition. [In Persian]
Motahari, Morteza (2003), Fitrat, Tehran: Sadra, first edition. [In Persian]
Motahari, Morteza (2009), Causes of the tendency towards materialism, Qom: Sadra Publications, 6th edition. [In Persian]
Panahi Azad, Hassan. (2008), Religious Pluralism and the Emerging Era, Mashreq Magazine, 2nd year, 8th issue. [In Persian]
Tavasoli, Gholam Abbas (1992), Sociological Theories, Tehran, Samt, first edition. [In Persian]
Yousefian, Hassan (2018), New Word, 4th edition, Tehran: Samt Publications. [In Persian]
Comparative Shiʿi Theology
Volume 4, Issue 7
September 2023
Pages 97-120

Home

Guide for Authors

Editorial Boards

Submit Manuscript

Contact Us